| Platinum | Dave's Gourmet Burgers and More |
| Gold | Wagon Train BBQ |
| Silver | Jumpin' Jack's Drive-In |
| Bronze | Tropics Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | 20 North Broadway Tavern |
| Top Pick | Manhattan Exchange |
| Top Pick | More Perreca's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Newest Lunch |
| Top Pick | Ruggiero's Pizza and Deli |
| Top Pick | Unbeetable |
